PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE ANALYSIS AND KULTURARBEIT
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32782/upj/2024-2-2-12Keywords:
practice analysis, Kulturarbeit, transference, professionalism, movements of disconnection, death wish, destructive violence.Abstract
Abstract. This paper was originally published in English in the journal Group Analysis (Sage) in 2012, Volume 45, Issue 2. It was republished due to the consent of the first author, Georges Gaillard, and the reprint rights purchased from Sage by the National Psychological Association. The paper discusses the psychoanalytically based psychological work needed by professionals working in the field of care and social work. The authors use Freud’s notion of “Kulturarbeit” (work of culture), further developed by the French psychoanalyst Nathalie Zaltzman, to describe the processes necessary to confront the radical negativity and deadly violence that characterize human beings. The article convincingly demonstrates that the failure of societal institutions to symbolize certain manifestations of humans creates a threat to the identification of some individuals with these manifestations. To be able to devote themselves to the different patients they work with daily, it is important for professionals to lend themselves to the patient’s transference, on the one hand, but on the other hand, not to be trapped in the enjoyment of this connection or contaminated by deadly processes. The authors propose that the restoration of Kulturarbeit in work with a patient’s suffering provided by the staff of a care facility can be based on a transformational group process using the method of professional practice analysis (PPA). The authors assume that the process of Kulturarbeit takes place in self-reflective spaces, for which PPA can serve as a paradigm. The clinical illustration provided in the article reveals the theoretical basis and the process of using the PPA method and sheds light on the challenges faced by professionals and the possible solutions that group work can offer. In general, the work of a PPA group allows a professional to withstand inevitable setbacks and maintain the transformational purpose of their practice.
References
Assoun, P.L. (1994). La psychanalyse à l’épreuve du pouvoir, in Analyse et réflexion sur le pouvoir, Volume II, Ouvrage collectif, pp. 59–71. Paris, Ellipses.
Aulagnier, P. (1975). La violence de l’interprétation. Du pictogramme à l’énoncé. (cf. P. Castoriadis-Aulagnier), Paris: Puf.
Aulagnier, P. (1984). The Apprentice Historian and the Master Magician, Paris: Puf.
Bion, W.R. (1961). Expériences in Group. Londres, Tavistock, trad fr. Recherches sur les petits groupes. Paris: PUF, 1965.
de M’Uzan, M. (1969). ‘Le même et l’identique’, in De l’art à la mort, (1977), pp. 83–97. Paris: Tél Gallimard.
Fédida, P. (2000). Humain / déshumain. L’oubli, l’effacement des traces, l’éradication subjective, la disparition,
in P. Fédida, J. André (ed.) Humains / déshumain, Pierre Fédida, la parole de l’oeuvre, pp. 11–125. Paris: Puf, 2007.
Freud, S. (1932). XXXI° leçon. in Nouvelle suite des leçons d’introduction à la psychanalyse, trad. franç. O.C. Vol XIX, 1995, Paris: Puf.
Fustier, P. (1999). Le travail d’équipe en institution. Clinique de l’institution médico-sociale et psychiatrique. Paris: Dunod.
Gaillard, G. (2008). Restaurer de la professionnalité. Analyse de la pratique et inter-subjectivité, Revue de Psychothérapie psychanalytique de groupe, 50: 33–46.
Green, A. (1983). Narcissisme de vie, narcissisme de mort, Paris: Les Éditions de Minuit.
Henri, A.N. (2009). Penser à partir de la pratique. Rencontre avec Alain-Noël Henri, Toulouse: Érès.
Henri, A.N. (2004). Le secret de famille et l’enfant improbable, in P. Mercader and A.N. Henri (ed.) La formation en psychologie filiation bâtarde, transmission troublée, pp. 193–303. Lyon: PUL.
Henri–Ménassé, C. (2009). Analyse de la pratique en institution. Scène, jeux, enjeux. Toulouse: Érès.
Kaës, R. (1987). Réalité psychique et souffrance dans les institutions, in R. Kaës (ed.) L’institution et les institutions, pp. 1–46. Paris: Dunod.
Kaës, R. (2009). Les alliances inconscientes. Paris: Dunod.
Zalzman, N. (1998). Psychoanalytic Healing. Paris: Puf, second revised edition, 1999.
Zalzman, N. (2007). The Spirit of Evil. Paris: Editions de l’Olivier.